Sunday, December 22, 2013

On This Day...


I have been entertaining myself this morning by thumbing through an assortment of diaries looking to see if anything exciting happened on this day in the lives of anyone. One book entitled English Diaries (1930) and edited by Elizabeth D'Oyley contains the musings of such worthies as Samuel Pepys, John Evelyn, Fanny Burney, Dorothy Wordsworth, Sir Walter Scott, and arctic explorer Captain Robert Scott.

I couldn't find any entries for December 22 by any of the diarists in that collection, so I turned to The Assassin's Cloak (2000) edited by Irene and Alan Taylor. This is a wonderful compendium of diary entries by a wild variety of folks and is both entertaining and thought provoking.

Here is one of the five entries included for today written down by J.R. Ackerley, a British writer and editor. Mr. Ackerley (1896-1967) was the literary editor of The Listener, the BBC's weekly magazine. I must say I have to agree with his sentiments... 

December 22, 1952

The Movietone News this week had a Christmas feature. A large number of flustered turkeys were driven towards the camera, and the commentator remarked that the Christmas rush was on, or words to that effect. Next they were seen crowded about their feeding trough, making the gobbling turkey fuss, and the commentator observed, with dry humour (again I do not remember his exact words), that it was no use their holding a protest meeting, for they were for it in the morning. Similar facetious jokes followed them wherever they went, hurrying and trampling about in their silly way; for to make them look as silly as possible was no doubt part of the joke and easy to achieve: turkeys, like hens, like all animals, are beautiful in themselves, and have even a kind of dignity when they are leading their own lives, but the fowls, in particular, look foolish when they are being frightened.

These jolly, lip-licking sallies, delivered in the rich, cultivated self-confident voice of one who has no sort of doubt of his own superiority to the animal kingdom, raised no laugh from the considerable audience, I was pleased to note. I took it from the silence that many other people besides myself would have been glad to be spared jeers and jibes at these creatures who, parting unwillingly with their lives, were to afford us pleasure at our Christmas tables. 

...How arrogant people are in their behaviour to the domestic beasts at least. Indeed, yes, we feed upon them, and enjoy their flesh; but does that permit us to make fun of them before they die or after they are dead? If it were possible, without disordering one's whole life, to be a vegetarian, I would be one; nothing could have been more disgusting and degrading than the insensitiveness displayed by the exhibition I have described.

8 comments:

  1. I'm a vegan, so I agree wholeheartedly with most of Mr. Ackerley's sentiments. I once started writing a poem I called "Christmas Isn't Merry for the Christmas Goose'. And it's not hard at all to be vegetarian or vegan. All you have to do is remember the suffering of the animals and the benefits to the earth and your health.

    Merry Christmas, Belle! Wishing you many good books and lots of reading time in 2014!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Way to go, Joan! I am about 99 per cent vegetarian (eggs and dairy though) but occasionally a little bit of flesh passes through my lips. And I always feel guilty. I agree that it is not all that difficult to give up meat, but perhaps in the 1950s there wasn't as much support for that decision as there is now.

      Thanks for reading all the way through Mr. Ackerley's diary entry. At first I thought it was going to be humorous but quickly saw that it was taking a serious tone. I hate those magazine ads that depict animals in a humiliating pose in an attempt to be funny...which they are not. I am thinking of one that is for kitty litter. Bah!

      Please finish your poem in defense of the Christmas Goose and I will post it here!

      Merry Christmas, Joan, to you and your family!

      Delete
  2. Thanks Joan, as a Buddhist (vegetarian) this season can be a challenge on so many levels.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree totally, Tullik. The season gets crazier and crazier and I find myself opting out more and more of the "what I am supposed to do's." I just appreciate the lights and the chilly nights and try to keep my focus on quiet and reflection. Easier said than done!

      Delete
  3. Thanks Belle
    "...the lights and the chilly nights and try to keep my focus on quiet and reflection" excellent suggestion!
    Merry Christmas to you and all your readers!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, Tullik. It is always good to hear from you!

      Delete
  4. As I began reading the diary entry, I expected that people hurrying about their desperate Christmas shopping (Black Friday comes to mind) would be compared to the turkeys' fuss and fluster. It took a different turn, but a thoughtful one for sure. I was reminded of the concept of being thankful and respectful of the animals that give their lives to feed us.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I had the same experience, Kathy - thinking this was a light-hearted entry. Not so! A timely reminder for everyone of us to show respect and kindness to all creatures.

      Delete